Amy Schumer Lists Brooklyn Townhouse, Plans Move Back to Manhattan.
Comedian and actress Amy Schumer is preparing to say goodbye to Brooklyn as she and her husband, chef Chris Fischer, list their Brooklyn Heights townhouse for $14 million. The couple, who purchased the home in 2022 for $12.25 million, are moving back to Manhattan to be closer to their son Gene’s school.
“He got into a good school and we’re too lazy to commute 45 minutes to take our son to school every day,” Schumer said with her signature humor.
The historic townhouse, built in 1829, holds a special place in film history, having served as the exterior for the Castorini family home in the 1987 classic Moonstruck, starring Cher and Nicolas Cage. Despite its storied past, Schumer and Fischer have made their own mark on the property.
“We loved what we moved into,” said Schumer, a New York native. “But we’ve definitely made it our own.”
Photo - Evan Joseph/Evan Joseph Studios/Corcoran; Realtor.com
One of their biggest updates was to the backyard, where they worked with renowned landscape architect Michael Van Valkenburgh, known for his work on Brooklyn Bridge Park. They replaced the brick patio with turf and added a play structure and swing to create a more child-friendly space. “Not that it’s a ton [of space],” Schumer quipped. “You know, it is Brooklyn.”
Photo - Evan Joseph/Evan Joseph Studios/Corcoran; Realtor.com
Spanning roughly 5,600 square feet, the home features five bedrooms, a gym, and a wine cellar. While its generous size has been a luxury, Schumer acknowledged that it feels larger than they need for their small family. “This is a home that is just ready for more people,” she said. Still, she admitted that leaving the neighborhood won’t be easy. “This neighborhood has just been a dream to live here, and I feel very sad to leave.”
LATEST: Fitness Guru Tracy Anderson Lists Two Luxury Homes for Sale Following Legal Settlement.
Schumer and Fischer’s decision to move comes after she sold her Upper West Side apartment for $13 million in 2023. Best known for her stand-up comedy and starring roles in films like Trainwreck, Snatched, and I Feel Pretty, Schumer is currently promoting her new Netflix film, Kinda Pregnant.
Photo - Evan Joseph/Evan Joseph Studios/Corcoran; Realtor.com
The Brooklyn real estate market remains strong, with demand on the rise. Sales in Brownstone Brooklyn, which includes Brooklyn Heights, surged 44.9% in the fourth quarter compared to the previous year, according to real estate appraisal firm Miller Samuel. The average sale price in the area also climbed 12.9% to $3.325 million during that period, reinforcing the borough’s appeal to buyers.
The listing is being handled by Adam Modlin of Modlin Group alongside Karen and Kyle Talbott of the Corcoran Group.
Photo - Evan Joseph/Evan Joseph Studios/Corcoran; Realtor.com
As Schumer and her family prepare for their next chapter, they leave behind a beautifully curated home that blends history with modern charm. Their move to Manhattan marks a return to familiar territory, allowing them to balance family life with the city’s vibrant culture and convenience. While parting with their Brooklyn Heights home is bittersweet, the transition represents an exciting new beginning for the comedian and her family. With her humor and adaptability, Schumer is sure to make their next residence just as special as the last.
